IIIT-Hyderabad Versus all IITsâ€â€the Lone Unforgettable Battle of Computer Science
International Institute of Information Technology-Hyderabad, or IIIT-H, was in news recently for charging IT companies planning to hire candidates from the campus. IT firms had to shell out 8 % of the total annual package received by the candidate. And despite a few exemptions of Indian firms, 28 top IT firms from across the globe not only paid the fee, but also hired 105 best candidates from the campus. This shows growing prominence of IIIT-H in India.
This growing prominence of IIIT-H in India is being questioned and drawing inevitable comparisons with none other than IITs. All right! That has become a sort of trend now. Any institution’s mounting popularity will be put to test or, obviously, compared with IITs. But what’s the truth here, in this case specifically?
“Is IIIT-H better than IITs in computer science?â€Âis a long debated question that pops out every time IIIT-H is mentioned in any discussion. The answer however eludes those seeking for one desperately.
When we talk about computer science specifically, IIIT-H obviously wins the battle. However, declaring IIIT-H better than IITs in computer science will not be entirely true. Keeping our discussion unbiased, we realize that the answer to the question, whether IIIT-H is better than IITs or not in computer science, depends a lot on various factors.
There is no doubt that IIIT-H is really good in computer science. But there are IITs with lots of departmentsin computer science and huge benefits of having those departments in the stream. If you really wish to learn good computer science then obviously IIIT-H is your best bet but what if your interest in computer science drops midway? With lots of department in computer science in any IIT, you can switch to other department or branch of your choice. Well, as an engineer, it is really important to experience and explore other options to make your learning stronger.
With an intensive computer science curriculum, IIIT-H focuses more on coding skills. This is not the case with IITs. They just introduce computer science to you the way it is. In fact, students might learn about machine learning and advanced algorithmsduring their 3rd or 4th year in IITs. But in IIIT-H, you might have an opportunity to learn about them in 2nd year itself. This directly translates into better internship and research opportunities at early stages.
IIIT-H brags a hardcore coding environment in the campus. Students take part in competition and perform exceptionally well. But that does not necessarily mean that IITs are far behind. They do well too. In fact, IITs pays more attention to the college curriculum. Its environment is more about college curriculum. Both are highly competitive in this particular sense.
If we try to judge the better of the two from the perspective of internships, then, again, there is a lot of disparity. When it comes to good job and internship offers then IIIT-H is really better than IIT-Guwahati, IIT-Roorkee, and other newer IITs. However, other IITs like IIT-Bombay, IIT-Delhi, IIT-Kharagpur, and IIT-Madras are far better than IITs. In fact, IIIT-H can’t even compete with them.
Global firms constantly search for excellent coders. They are not really interested in your coursework at all. So in that sense, IIIT-H performs better than newer IITs.
IITs give you their tag to you but you can’t live your entirely on that tag. Your skills will be tested once you will step out in the real brutal world. If you are damn serious about doing computer science anyway and haven’t got one in one of IITs of your choice, then opting for the stream in IIIT-H is a better option.
Finally, the answer to the questionâ€â€Is IIIT-H better than IITs in computer science?â€â€dependsentirely upon your requirements and other factors. Both institutions are great and have made the country proud. You must evaluate your needs before you make any decision.
4th paragraph, second line, typo. Its IIIT-H and not IIT-H
Thanks !
IIIT has been workin out a long time now. They practice more body weight exercises and rely on healthy food, while IITs go for steroids and do only cardio. Hence long term results have been good.. You can see from the biceps on the above picture also..
I feel that this blog is a little bit biased. There are many research centers in computer science at IIIT-H like computer vision, machine learning, data mining, robotics, etc… And its totally wrong that IIIT-H is only strong in coding. I have worked closely with many graduates, post-graduates and more so with doctorates from IITs (like Kharagpur, Kanpur, Madras, etc) and honestly I dont see any titanic effect of curriculum on them. The B. Tech graduates from IITs are very good in coding (as much as IIIT-H) and that is their major strength. I didn’t notice anything special that they have gained from their curriculum; no research skills, inability to read and understand research papers, etc… Talking about the doctorates from IITs, I would just ask all of you to just look at the publications they make: Very few of them in reputed conferences and Journals and most of them in give-away journals and conferences. On the other hand even masters students in IIIT-H publish in highly reputed journals and conferences. In my opinion, that credit goes to the academic curriculum of IIIT-H. To summarize, IIIT-H’s curriculum is strong enough to provide excellent coding skills as well as whatever else in required to excel in computer science whether it be research or entrepreneurship.
It is mentioned that IIIT-H is no where near The old IITs like Bombay,Delhi,etc.Does that include IIT-BHU Varanasi too?
true where is IIT varanasi , i don’t understand why always people left IIT varanasi while talking about IITs are they idiot ? even it is the one of the best institution in India.
ALMOST HALF OF GUYS DOING CSE IN LEADING IIT,S ARE RESERVED CATEGORY.IIIT H TAKES ONLY JEE MAINS MARK.
MAJORITY OF RESRVED CAT GUYS DOING CSE MAY NOT GET SEAT IN IIIT H BECAUSE THERE IS NO RESERVATION.INTERNATIONAL RECRUITERS ARE AWARE OF IT.I HOPE ANSWER IS CLEAR.IIT,S COMPROMISE ON MERIT.50% SEATS ARE RESERVED.HOW CAN THE OVER ALL QUALITY BE GOOD.
The quality of students can never be the sole criterion to judge the quality of an institute… JEE Advanced is almost three times as tough as JEE Main. This clearly speaks that students who got CSE at old IITs are much intelligent and hard-working than those who got CSE at IIITH…
but admission is competitive(rank based) not score based so level of questions has nothing to do with it. IIITH invites some of the top rankers of JEE main.
Yes and thats the reason the difference in skill that people having 1k-2k rank quit IIT’s and get admitted to IIIT-H don’t be a fool
AIR 1500 is really a big deal
Let’s get this straight by drawing an analogy. Two students fighting for their superiority when both have scored below 50 (min pass marks) at international level. This is a pointless fight! We should look at impact of the work, the theoretical foundation of the students from both the institutes. What are the top ranked journals where the faculty has been publishing & what has been the citation index / impact factor of each of these publications? It is not the number but the quality of publications that matter. Satyen Bose had probably <10 publications in his life, but look at the impact! 6 Nobel Laureates came out of his work and that happened (Yr: 1924) 90 years ago itself! How many publications from these institutes are in journals such as "Foundations and Trends in Theoretical Computer Science", "SIAM Journal On Computing", "ACM Computing Surveys" etc. So, friends, let us be sober and debate about the right problems.
IIT’s maybe not a lifelong tag but they are an access card to further studies and interviews , how often do we see a non CSE excellent coder getting a great job?
there are lakhs of such students who are in different branches but great in CS and coding!
Only a handful of them get proper work environment or opportunities